I had the same issue so the next foundation I ordered came from the second level of intensity. I ordered bisque neutral and the color was perfect. If you feel you have neither a red or pink undertone to your skin or a yellow undertone you can always order a neutral version of your shade. This is determines by the letter N in parenthesis. I was sent a brochure that shows shades available with holes in them to allow you to put it next to yous skin to find the closest match to your skin tone. I hope this has helped. You should be able to send your shade back and get the right one.
2 years ago